Why Anxiously Attached People Struggle with Break-Ups

THE BLOG

Stephanie Rigg

I'm

STEPHANIE

Nice to meet you! I'm a relationship coach and host of the On Attachment podcast. My work will support you to build self-worth, break free from old patterns, and create more secure, fulfilling relationships.

TOP LINKS

instagram

YOUTUBE

PODCAST

Get The Starter Kit

Anxious Attachment Starter Kit

Get my Anxious Attachment Starter Kit to start your journey to healthier relationships.

If you have an anxious attachment style, chances are you don’t need anyone to tell you that break-ups can feel utterly destabilising. More than any other attachment pattern, anxious attachment tends to amplify the emotional fallout of a relationship ending, leaving people feeling unmoored, intensely lonely, and gripped by a desperate urge to reconnect.

In this piece, I want to offer some context for why break-ups can be so uniquely painful for anxiously attached people, and how understanding these dynamics can help you move through this season with more compassion, steadiness, and self-trust.

1. The Primacy of Connection

For anxiously attached people, connection isn’t just meaningful — it’s synonymous with safety. Romantic partnership often becomes the primary source of emotional regulation, reassurance, and stability. The underlying equation is simple: if we’re okay, I’m okay.

This reliance on connection isn’t inherently wrong, but it becomes problematic when a romantic relationship is carrying too much weight — when it becomes the sole source of safety, meaning, and emotional comfort. This often goes hand in hand with an underdeveloped sense of self and limited capacity to self-soothe, both of which are common in anxious attachment.

When another person becomes your emotional anchor and power source, you’re left profoundly vulnerable if that bond is threatened. A break-up doesn’t just end the relationship — it dismantles the very system that’s been holding you together. Even if the relationship was unhealthy or deeply unsatisfying, the loss of connection can still feel utterly devastating.

If the anxious attachment mantra is if we’re okay, I’m okay, then the inverse is also true: if we’re not okay, I’m not okay. After a break-up, the problems that once plagued the relationship can feel insignificant compared to the sheer emptiness left behind. The urge to reconnect isn’t about logic or compatibility — it’s about survival.

In many ways, a break-up pulls the rug out from under the anxiously attached person, leaving them flailing in deep water, having never been given the chance to learn how to stay afloat on their own.

2. Break-Ups Activate the Abandonment Wound

At the core of anxious attachment lies the abandonment wound — the deep-seated fear of being unlovable, unchosen, or ultimately left behind. It’s the belief that we’re too much or not enough, and that rejection and loss are always waiting just around the corner.

A break-up has a way of activating this wound with brutal efficiency. It can feel like confirmation of every painful story you’ve carried about yourself — that you weren’t worthy, that you cared more, that if you’d just been different in some way, things might have worked out.

This often fuels intense shame and self-blame. Anxiously attached people are prone to replaying the relationship through a harsh, self-critical lens, cataloguing their perceived mistakes while overlooking the relational dynamics, incompatibilities, and unmet needs that also contributed to the relationship ending.

Rather than holding the break-up as a shared outcome of two people and a complex system, the anxious mind turns it into a personal indictment — a story that keeps the wound alive and prolongs the pain.

3. The Saviour Complex

Many people with anxious attachment carry some version of a saviour complex — a subconscious pull towards partners they feel compelled to help, heal, or transform. This often shows up as a fixation on someone’s potential, while minimising or rationalising the reality of who they are in the present.

In relationships, this can turn into an unspoken mission: If I can just get them to change, then everything will be okay. Beneath that hope often sits a quieter belief: And then I’ll finally feel worthy.

When so much energy is invested in trying to reshape a partner or the relationship, a break-up can feel like a catastrophic personal failure. It’s not just the loss of the relationship — it’s the collapse of the project. The story becomes: If I’d been more attractive, more relaxed, less needy, more confident — they would have chosen me.

What’s especially painful here is that so much of this suffering comes from taking responsibility for something that was never yours to carry: another person’s willingness or capacity to meet you in the way you needed.

4. Break-Ups Mean Uncertainty (and Anxious Attachment Hates Uncertainty)

Another reason break-ups hit anxious attachers so hard is the sheer uncertainty they introduce. Even a dysfunctional relationship can feel safer than the unknown — it’s the devil you know.

Anxiety craves predictability and control, or at least the illusion of it. After a break-up, this often shows up as rumination, obsessive thinking, rereading old messages, or compulsively checking social media. These behaviours aren’t random — they’re attempts to gather information, make meaning, and regain a sense of control.

But a break-up inevitably ushers in a liminal period — a transition that demands we tolerate ambiguity, unanswered questions, and not knowing what comes next. For the anxiously attached person, this can feel excruciating, but it’s also where profound growth becomes possible.

5. Self-Abandonment and Loss of Identity

Finally, many anxiously attached people have a tendency to self-abandon in relationships. As the relationship becomes more strained, attention narrows, and increasing amounts of time, energy, and emotional labour are poured into keeping the connection alive — often at the expense of friendships, interests, and personal goals.

When the relationship ends, this creates a double loss. Not only is the partner gone, but so too is the sense of identity that had become entwined with the relationship. Looking around, it can feel as though there’s very little left to land on.

While this can be incredibly confronting, it’s also why break-ups can ultimately become turning points for anxiously attached people. They invite a return to self — an opportunity to rebuild identity, safety, and self-worth from the inside out. Still, the initial realisation that you don’t quite know who you are without the other person can bring with it a deep and very real grief.

And that grief deserves to be met with patience, tenderness, and care

Hi, I'm Stephanie

Hi, I’m Stephanie. I’m a relationship coach and host of the On Attachment podcast. I help people understand their attachment patterns, build deep self-worth, and create more secure, fulfilling relationships — with others and with themselves.

Take The Quiz

Discover Your Attachment Style

Take a short quiz to discover your attachment style and get a free 30-page guide to understanding your relationship patterns.

SIGNATURE COURSE

Healing

ANXIOUS

ATTACHMENT

A practical, compassionate program to help you stop overthinking love, trust yourself again, and build relationships that don’t cost you your sense of self.

Explore the Course →

Guiding you beyond anxious attachment to deep self-worth, secure relationships, and a life you love.

Follow along →

Follow along →